AFL
| Year | Coach | Captains | Chairman | CEO | Position | Kevin Sheedy Medallist | Leading Goalkicker | All-Australian |
| 2012 | Kevin Sheedy | Callan Ward, Phil Davis, Luke Power |
Tony Shepherd, AO | David Matthews | 18th | Callan Ward | Jeremy Cameron (29) |
- |
| 2013 | Kevin Sheedy | Callan Ward, Phil Davis |
Tony Shepherd, AO | David Matthews | 18th | Jeremy Cameron | Jeremy Cameron (62) |
Jeremy Cameron |
| 2014 | Leon Cameron | Callan Ward, Phil Davis |
Tony Shepherd, AO | David Matthews | 16th | Shane Mumford |
Jeremy Cameron (29) |
- |
| 2015 | Leon Cameron | Callan Ward, Phil Davis |
Tony Shepherd, AO | David Matthews | 11th | Heath Shaw | Jeremy Cameron (63) |
Heath Shaw |
| 2016 | Leon Cameron | Callan Ward, Phil Davis |
Tony Shepherd, AO | David Matthews | 4th | Toby Greene | Jeremy Cameron (53) |
Toby Greene, Heath Shaw |
| 2017 | Leon Cameron | Callan Ward, Phil Davis |
Tony Shepherd, AO | David Matthews | 4th | Josh Kelly |
Jeremy Cameron, |
Josh Kelly, Dylan Shiel |
| 2018 | Leon Cameron | Callan Ward, Phil Davis |
Tony Shepherd, AO | David Matthews | 6th | Lachie Whitfield | Jeremy Cameron (46) | Lachie Whitfield |
| 2019 | Leon Cameron | Callan Ward, Phil Davis |
Tony Shepherd, AO | David Matthews | 2nd | Tim Taranto | Jeremy Cameron (76) | Jeremy Cameron |
| 2020 | Leon Cameron | Stephen Coniglio | Tony Shepherd, AO | David Matthews | 10th | Nick Haynes and Lachie Whitfield | Jeremy Cameron (24) | Nick Haynes |
| 2021 | Leon Cameron | Stephen Coniglio | Tony Shepherd, AO | David Matthews | 6th | Josh Kelly | Toby Greene (42) | Toby Greene |
| 2022 | Leon Cameron/Mark McVeigh (interim) | Stephen Coniglio, Josh Kelly, Toby Greene | Tony Shepherd, AO | David Matthews | 16th | Sam Taylor | Toby Greene (37) | Sam Taylor |
| 2023 | Adam Kingsley | Toby Greene | Tony Shepherd, AO | David Matthews | 4th | Toby Greene | Toby Greene (66) | Toby Greene - Captain |
AFLW
| Year | Coach | Captain | Chairman | CEO | Position | Gabrielle Trainor Medallist | Leading Goalkicker | All-Australian |
| 2017 | Tim Schmidt | Amanda Farrugia | Tony Shepherd, AO | David Matthews | 8th | Jessica Dal Pos | Phoebe McWilliams (7) |
Jessica Dal Pos |
| 2018 | Alan McConnell | Amanda Farrugia | Tony Shepherd, AO | David Matthews | 4th | Alicia Eva | Phoebe McWilliams (7) |
Alicia Eva, Courtney Gum, Erin McKinnon |
| 2019 | Alan McConnell | Amanda Farrugia | Tony Shepherd, AO | David Matthews | 3rd in Conference B | Rebecca Beeson | Christina Bernardi (7) | - |
| 2020 | Alan McConnell | Alicia Eva | Tony Shepherd, AO | David Matthews | Season abandoned (COVID) | Alyce Parker | Cora Staunton (8) | Alyce Parker |
| 2021 | Alan McConnell | Alicia Eva | Tony Shepherd, AO | David Matthews | 9th | Alyce Parker | Cora Staunton (10) | Alyce Parker |
| 2022 | Alan McConnell | Alicia Eva | Tony Shepherd, AO | David Matthews | 9th | Alyce Parker | Cora Staunton (18) | - |
| 2022 S7 | Cameron Bernasconi | Alicia Eva | Tony Shepherd, AO | David Matthews | 11th | Alyce Parker | Cora Staunton (8) | - |
